How to rate a risk

Every risk on your event's risk register is rated twice: before controls (as if you did nothing) and after the controls you will put in place. The rating comes from two questions: how bad could it be (consequence) and how likely is it (likelihood)?

1Describe the riskWhat is the hazard, and what could actually happen? For example: "Hot BBQ plate – a child is burned."
2Choose the consequence (1–5)The most serious realistic outcome. Check every column below and use the highest.
3Choose the likelihood (A–E)How likely is that outcome at this event, with these people and this venue?
4Add controls and re-rateList what you will do, then choose consequence and likelihood again. The form works out both ratings for you.

Step 2 – Consequence: how bad could it be?

Look across all four columns and choose the highest level that realistically applies. A minor injury that leads to a safeguarding report is a 3, not a 2.

LevelPeopleSafeguardingMoney or propertyReputation or compliance
1 – InsignificantNo injuryNo concernUnder $500None
2 – MinorFirst aid onlyMinor concern, handled locally$500 – $5,000Local talk or a single complaint
3 – ModerateMedical treatment (doctor, GP)A concern that must be reported$5,000 – $50,000Community complaint or local media
4 – MajorSerious injury or hospital admissionIncident or allegation involving a child or vulnerable person$50,000 – $500,000State media or a regulator notice
5 – CatastrophicDeath or permanent disabilityAbuse with police involvementOver $500,000National media or prosecution

Controls usually reduce likelihood. Consequence only drops when a control changes how bad the outcome can be: for example a lifeguard, a barrier, or removing the hazard altogether.

Step 3 – Likelihood: how likely is it?

LevelDefinitionThink of it as…
A – Almost certainExpected to occur in most circumstancesIt happens at most events like this one.
B – LikelyWill probably occur in most circumstancesIt has happened at similar GCI events, or you would not be surprised.
C – PossibleMight occur at some stageIt could happen; you have heard of it happening elsewhere.
D – UnlikelyCould occur at some stage, but not likelyIt would be unusual; nobody you know has seen it happen.
E – RareOnly in exceptional circumstancesIt would take a freak combination of events.

The GCI risk matrix

Find the likelihood row and the consequence column. Where they meet is the rating.

Likelihood ↓   Consequence →1
Insignificant
2
Minor
3
Moderate
4
Major
5
Catastrophic
A – Almost certain Low-ModerateHighExtremeExtremeExtreme
B – Likely Low-ModerateHighHighExtremeExtreme
C – Possible LowModerateHighExtremeExtreme
D – Unlikely LowLowModerateHighExtreme
E – Rare LowLowModerateModerateHigh

What the rating after controls means

Rating after controlsWhat happens
Low Low-ModerateAcceptable. Carry out the controls as planned. Your Senior Pastor approves the event.
ModerateAcceptable with care. Make sure the responsible person knows the controls. Your Senior Pastor approves the event.
HighOnly acceptable with strong controls. After your Senior Pastor, the General Manager (National Office) also approves the event.
ExtremeUnacceptable as planned. You can still submit, but the event will not be approved until the risk is reduced. National Office will contact you about changes, or the activity may need to be removed.

Step 4 – Choosing good controls

Use the strongest control you reasonably can. Work down this list (the "hierarchy of controls"):

Control typeMeaningExample
1. EliminateRemove the hazard completely.Skip the creek crossing; hold the game on grass, not concrete.
2. SubstituteSwap it for something safer.Electric urn instead of a gas burner; soft balls instead of hard ones.
3. EngineerPut a physical barrier or safeguard in place.Fence or barrier around the BBQ; cable covers; shade sails.
4. Admin / procedureRules, supervision, briefings, signs, checklists.Named supervisor; two-adult rule; head count before leaving; briefing.
5. PPEProtective equipment people wear.Gloves, hats and sunscreen, hi-vis, closed shoes.
If your only controls are admin or PPE and the risk started as High or Extreme, ask whether a stronger control is possible.

Worked examples

Picnic – hot BBQ plate, child is burned

Before controls
Consequence 2 – Minor (first aid)
Likelihood C – Possible
Rating Moderate
→
With controls: barrier around the BBQ, one adult cooks, children kept back, burns gel in the first aid kit.
Consequence 2, likelihood D – Unlikely
Rating Low

Working bee – fall from a ladder

Before controls
Consequence 4 – Major (hospital)
Likelihood C – Possible
Rating Extreme
→
With controls: no roof work, ladders checked and footed by a second person, only experienced volunteers climb.
Consequence 4, likelihood E – Rare
Rating Moderate

Beach outing – a swimmer gets into difficulty

Before controls
Consequence 5 – Catastrophic (drowning)
Likelihood C – Possible
Rating Extreme
→
With controls: patrolled beach, swim between the flags only, adult water-watchers, children within arm's reach.
Consequence 5, likelihood E – Rare
Rating High – so National Office also approves.

Tips

  • Be realistic, not worst-case-for-everything. Rate the most serious outcome that could reasonably happen at this event.
  • Use the suggested risks. On the risk register page, "Add this risk" fills in a typical rating and controls for your event type. Adjust them to suit your event.
  • Name a responsible person for each risk, and brief them before the day.
  • Not sure? Ask your Senior Pastor, or contact National Office.

Go to the event risk assessment